10 November 2026
How to Tell If Your Ad Agency Is Actually Working: A KPI Checklist

You pay your agency every month. You get a report full of charts, and the numbers go up and down. But you can’t tell whether the money is working, whether a slow month is the agency’s fault or yours, or what you should be asking. Here’s a way to judge it without becoming an ads expert.
The short answer
An agency is working if you can trace your spend to leads and customers you recognise, at a cost that makes sense for your business, with clear explanations when things go wrong. If you can’t see that chain, the problem is either the results or the reporting, and either one is worth raising.
Start with the number that matters: what a lead is worth to you
You can’t judge performance without your own break-even point. Work out profit per customer and close rate, and from them your break-even cost per lead. Our posts on how much to budget for Facebook and Google Ads and on what a good cost per lead is show how. Without it, every number in the report is just a number.
The KPI ladder: read your report from the top
Reports often lead with what looks impressive, and not with what matters. Read them in this order:
| Level | What it tells you | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Business outcomes | Did the ads produce customers? | Sales, bookings, revenue from ads |
| 2. Lead quality | Were the leads real? | Contacted, qualified, converted |
| 3. Efficiency | What did each result cost? | Cost per lead, cost per qualified lead, cost per customer |
| 4. Diagnostics | Why did it move? | Click-through rate, cost per click, conversion rate of the page, frequency |
| 5. Vanity metrics | Context only | Reach, impressions, likes, followers |
A report that stops at level 5 is telling you the ads were seen, not whether they worked. Reach and impressions are fine as background, but they can rise while your leads fall.
The KPI checklist
Ask whether your monthly report clearly shows each of these:
- Leads, counted by a definition you agreed
- Cost per lead, and ideally cost per qualified lead
- Leads by source and campaign, so you can see what’s working
- Calls and WhatsApp enquiries, not only form fills, since many Malaysian customers message first
- What happened to the leads: contacted, qualified, converted
- Spend against budget, with the fee shown separately from ad spend
- Trend over time, not only this month, and a comparison with the same period last year
- What was tested, what was learned and what’s next
- Problems and risks, stated plainly
If most of these are missing, you can’t judge the agency, and you shouldn’t be asked to take it on trust.
Step 1: Check the tracking before you judge the results
Numbers from broken tracking are meaningless, whoever supplies them. Check:
- Do the leads in the report match leads you actually received? Compare the report with your own inbox, sheet or CRM for one month.
- Is every lead channel counted? Forms, calls, WhatsApp clicks and walk-ins from ads.
- Is anything double-counted? The same person can appear more than once.
- Is the conversion event correct? A “lead” that fires on a page view isn’t a lead.
- Can you log in yourself? You should be able to see the accounts and the raw data.
If the report and your records disagree, resolve that first. It isn’t an argument about performance, it’s a question about whether the data can be trusted.
Step 2: Compare against your baseline and your break-even
Ask three questions:
- Is the cost per lead below your break-even? If it isn’t, the campaign is losing money per lead, however it looks.
- Is it better or worse than before the agency started? Compare against your own history, not against a generic industry number.
- Is the trend improving? Early months are for learning, so look for direction over a quarter, not a perfect month.
Step 3: Look at lead quality, not just lead volume
A low cost per lead can hide bad leads: wrong people, wrong area, fake numbers or people who never answer. You’ll need to give feedback for this to work.
- Tell the agency which leads were good and which were junk.
- Track how many leads you reached, qualified and closed.
- Compare sources. One campaign may be cheaper per lead but much worse per customer.
If your team isn’t recording outcomes, the agency can’t optimise for them. This one needs both sides.
Step 4: Separate what the agency controls from what it doesn’t
Fairness matters here, because ads results depend on more than the ads:
| The agency usually controls | You usually control |
|---|---|
| Campaign structure and targeting | Your offer and pricing |
| Ad creative and testing plan | Your landing page and website, unless the agency builds it |
| Tracking setup | How fast and well leads are followed up |
| Budget pacing and optimisation | Sales process and closing |
| Reporting and communication | Giving timely approvals and feedback |
If leads arrive but nobody answers for hours, no agency can fix that. (See our posts on automating lead routing and signs your website is losing leads.) If the page is the problem, ask whether the agency flagged it. A good agency tells you when the weak link is on your side.
Step 5: Check how they work, not just what they report
- Is there a testing log? What’s been tried, what happened and what’s next.
- Is creative refreshed regularly, or is the same ad running for months? (Our e-commerce case study and our post on why cost per lead rises show why this matters.)
- Do they explain changes, or do numbers move with no account of why?
- Do they raise problems before you do?
- Is anyone reachable, with realistic response times?
- Do you know who actually works on your account?
Step 6: Check ownership and access
This protects you whatever the results:
- The ad accounts, pixel and analytics should be in your business’s name, with the agency given access.
- You should have admin access, and be able to see billing.
- Ad spend should go to the platform, and the agency’s fee should be shown separately.
- You should have a copy of reports, creative and tracking details.
- Know the notice period and what handover looks like.
If the agency owns the accounts and you can’t see inside them, that’s worth fixing now, while the relationship is good.
Account for Malaysia’s calendar
Costs and lead volume shift around Hari Raya, Chinese New Year, 11.11 and year-end sales. A worse month during a peak isn’t necessarily a failing agency. Compare against the same period last year, and ask for a plan before peaks, such as extra creative, adjusted budgets and expectations.
Warning signs
- Reports built around reach, impressions and likes, with no leads, costs or outcomes
- No access to your own accounts
- Results explained only by “the algorithm” or “the season,” with no plan
- No tests, no log, no new ideas
- Guaranteed results, or pressure to raise spend before explaining performance
- Reluctance to share raw data, or numbers that don’t reconcile with yours
- No mention of lead quality or what happens after the lead
- Constant excuses, never questions about your offer, page or follow-up
- Vague answers to specific questions
One of these may be a communication problem. Several together point to a bigger issue.
A monthly review you can run in 30 minutes
- Compare the report’s leads with your own records.
- Check cost per lead against your break-even and last month’s figure.
- Review lead quality with your team, and pass it to the agency.
- Ask what was tested, what was learned and what’s planned next month.
- Look at anything unusual, such as a spike, a drop or a campaign paused.
- Agree on actions, owners and dates, and write them down.
If you think it isn’t working
- Check your own side first: the offer, the page, the follow-up speed and the tracking.
- Raise it directly, with specific numbers and questions, not general unhappiness.
- Agree a short improvement plan with clear measures and a date.
- Get an independent audit if you can’t tell where the problem is. A second opinion on the account, tracking and page can settle it. Some agencies, including us, offer audits or demos for eligible clients (see our post on free demos).
- If it doesn’t improve, use your notice terms and make sure you retain your accounts and data. Our agency buyer’s checklist covers what to look for in the next one.
The honest summary
A good agency gives you clear numbers, explains them, tests new ideas and tells you where the real problems are, including on your side. A poor one hides behind charts. You don’t need technical knowledge to tell the difference. You need your own break-even number, access to your own data, and the habit of asking the same few questions every month.
Not sure whether your ads agency is delivering, or want an independent look at your campaigns and tracking? [See how we run Facebook and Google Ads campaigns →]